๐Ÿ”ฅSPX Broken Wing Butterfly: The Strategy Behind My 83% Win Rate

A Broken Wing Butterfly on SPX, actively traded in my account since October 2021.

๐Ÿ“Š 83% win rate ยท ๐Ÿ’ฐ Avg $1,090 profit per trade ยท ๐Ÿ“ˆ ~15% monthly return ยท ๐Ÿ”„ 3 open positions simultaneously

Verified monthly on the Trading Account page โ†’

What you get on day one:

โœ… Full SPX Best course โ€” 38 lessons across 10 chapters + Greeks appendix

โœ… Discord trading room โ€” every live trade posted in real time

โœ… Community Center archive โ€” 250+ documented past trades

โœ… Implied Volatility Weekly newsletter

โœ… Direct access to me in Discord, every trading day

Description


The SPX Best isn't a strategy you learn in a weekend. It's a discretionary approach โ€” which means the entry logic, strike selection, and adjustment decisions require market judgment that develops over time from watching real trades happen in real conditions."

"That's why the course lives inside the Trading Community. Members don't just study the framework โ€” they follow every live trade I place using this strategy, with the full rationale posted in real time. That combination of structured education and live trade observation is what actually builds competence. Reading alone doesn't.


What the SPX Best strategy is

The SPX Best uses a broken wing butterfly (BWB) structure on SPX put options. It is a non-directional, income-generating strategy that profits from two sources:

  • Theta decay โ€” the position generates positive theta from day one. Time passing works in your favor.

  • IV contraction โ€” the position is Vega negative. When implied volatility decreases after a spike, the position benefits.

The structure targets a wide price range where SPX can move โ€” up, down, or sideways โ€” while still delivering a profit. This is what "non-directional" means in practice: not that the market must stay flat, but that the position is built to profit across a broad range of market outcomes.

What makes it different from a standard butterfly:

A broken wing butterfly is asymmetric โ€” the wings are not equal width. This creates a position with a credit at entry (you receive premium) and defined risk on one side only. The skewed structure allows for more aggressive theta collection while keeping the risk profile manageable and adjustable.

Minimum account size: $4,000 suggested. Typical capital allocated per position: ~$7,000.

Time commitment: 15โ€“30 minutes per day to monitor. Adjustments average less than once per week outside of the final 30 DTE period.


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Strategy live performance (through Nov 25):

In 2021 (starting in October) and the difficult trading times of 2022, the trade produced 10 wins in 15 trades opened (70% win rate). Until Nov 25, the performance increased to 52 wins, over 63 trades opened (historically, is circa 83% win rate). Each positive trade delivered an average profit of $1,090. Considering an average of $7000 investment per trade, the return is roughly 15% per month (each trade is opened about 1 to 1.5 months). Most of my Hedge Fund performance comes from this strategy! We have 3 open trades at a time under different time frames.

Check this CASE STUDY of a past real SPX Best trade.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



The SPX Best is the primary driver of my fund's overall performance. The full monthly fund record โ€” going back to January 2022 โ€” is publicly available on the Trading Account page. Every trade, every month.

โ†’ View the complete performance record

What happens inside the course. The SPX Best course includes:

  • Strategy Course โ€” the complete framework: how the BWB structure is constructed, how strikes are selected, what the adjustment rules are, and when and how to exit.

  • Risk profile walkthroughs โ€” how to read the payoff diagram in thinkorswim, what the Greeks look like at entry and how they evolve through the trade, what delta targets to maintain.

  • Live trade access (Trading Community) โ€” every SPX Best position I open is posted in the Discord trading room in real time: the strikes selected, the entry rationale, the payoff diagram, and the brokerage screenshot. You see exactly what I trade and why, the moment I trade it.

  • Trade posts with full adjustment history โ€” after every adjustment and at close, a full trade post is published to the Community Center showing the cumulative P&L, each fill, and the reasoning behind every decision.

    I am actively trading this strategy, which is delivering exceptional results. You will gain access to all my trades in the Trading Community, which also includes access to a live trading room (Discord Channel) where you can interact with me. The trades are announced there when I enter them into the trading platform.

    This options management style can be implemented with a minimum suggested account value of USD4000.


    ๐Ÿ‘‰ New to MyOptionsEdge? Start with the $59/mo Trading Room plan โ€” 15-day free trial, see every live trade I post, decide from there.

    ๐Ÿ‘‰ Want to learn SPX Best properly? This plan: $129/mo for flexibility, or $999/yr to save $549.

    ๐Ÿ‘‰ Want everything? Full Access includes all 13 strategy courses for $700 more.


A Real Trade Example

In November 2025 I opened an SPX Best position on 26 November, made one adjustment on 8 January 2026, and closed on 15 January 2026 with a $1,605 profit against a $1,500 target โ€” in 50 days.

Every fill, every rationale, and every screenshot from that trade is documented in the case study post: โ†’ Read the full SPX Best trade case study

This is what members see for every trade โ€” not in a case study written after the fact, but in real time as the trade is happening.

Course Contents

CHAPTER 1 - COURSE INTRODUCTION & WHY THIS STRATEGY

Welcome and What You Will Learn
Preview
Why the Best Strategy? Core Philosophy
Preview
What Is a Broken Wing Butterfly (BWB)?
Preview

CHAPTER 2 - TECHNICAL ANALYSIS FOUNDATIONS

Support and Resistance Explained
Drawing Support & Resistance Zones on SPX
Why Key Market Zones Matter for This Strategy

CHAPTER 3 - THE BEST STRATEGY: CORE CONCEPTS

Strategy Brief: The Full Picture
When to Open the Trade
The Best Strategy Option Properties

CHAPTER 4 - ANATOMY OF A TRADE AT OPEN

Illustration: Opening a Trade at 67 DTE
Illustration: Opening a Trade at 32 DTE

CHAPTER 5 - TRADE DYNAMICS OVER TIME

In Chapter 4 we saw what the trade looks like at the moment of entry. Now we want to see how it EVOLVES as days pass and the market does (or doesn't) move. Understanding the natural trajectory of the trade โ€” without any adjustments โ€” is the key to knowing when an adjustment is needed and when it isn't.

How the Trade Evolves

CHAPTER 6 - RULES TO OPEN A TRADE

Where to Center the Short Strikes
Options Chain Selection: Picking the Right DTE
Aggressive Positioning: 31 / 38 / 66 DTE Compared
Conservative Positioning: 31 / 38 / 66 DTE Compared

CHAPTER 7 - ADDING A "SOFT HEDGE"

Why and When to Add a Short Call Vertical
Conservative Soft Hedge Configuration
Aggressive Soft Hedge Configuration

CHAPTER 8 โ€” LEARNINGS FROM PRACTICE & SPECIAL SETUPS

Before we move into trade management and adjustments, let me share the most important things I've learned from trading this strategy live, over many cycles.

Practical Lessons From Live Trading
Selecting Shorter DTE in High IV Environments
Aggressive Setups Near the Upper Long Put

CHAPTER 9 - TRADE MANAGEMENT & ADJUSTMENTS

This is the most important chapter of the course. Opening the trade is easy. MANAGING it well โ€” making the right adjustment at the right time โ€” is where the strategy's true edge lives.

Adjustment Philosophy and Principles
Starting Position Example
Scenario: SPX Moves Up After 10 Days (No Adjust)
Scenario: SPX Continues Up After 25 Days (19 DTE)
Adjustment Alternative 1: Shorten the Upper Wing
Close vs. Continue: The 5 DTE Decision
Adjustment Alternative 2: "Condorize"
Re-Adjustment: Restoring Positive Delta
Scenario: Market Retracts
Aggressive Trade: When Price Touches Short Strikes
Re-Positioning to a 50/60 BWB

CHAPTER 10 - FINAL COMMENTS & WRAP-UP

Final Thoughts and Best Practices

APPENDIX - The GREEKS Explained

Quick-reference appendix on the four Greeks that drive every options trade. Useful for refreshing your fundamentals or onboarding less-experienced members.

Delta
Gamma
Theta
Vega

Frequently asked questions

Youโ€™ve got questions. Iโ€™ve got answers.

In what market conditions is this strategy best used?

The SPX Best Strategy is best used in a high IV market environment or in a falling IV. This strategy uses a butterfly options strategy that is Vega negative and, hence, will benefit from a decreasing IV environment. But, I am using it at any given time.

What is the profitability of this strategy?

The average expected profit is about 10-15% per month. Nevertheless, the market may react negatively to the position and produce losses. In these cases, there are specific guidelines to have risk under control. The strategy was strongly positive in the last quarter of 2021 (in an increasing SPX) and in the first half of 2022 when the market moved down, the strategy is showing also strong positive results.

Do you offer trade signals of your trades?

Indeed! I am trading my own Hedge Fund, where I am using this strategy. Everyone who wants to access my trades can enroll in the trading community, where I am disclosing all fund trades in real-time through a Discord channel.

Do you provide trade resumes and explanations?

Indeed. All trading community subscribers will receive an explanation of each trade and the evolution of the adjustments made during the open trade period. This can be accessed via the community web post as well as by email when it is published.

Here you have an example:



Every post is composed of:

1. Trade rationale;
2. Screenshot of options structure risk profile from Thinkorswim platform;
3. Screenshot of "filled orders" tab from Thinkorswing platform;
4. Position status with all the adjustments performed on the trade for easier following and understanding of profitability;
3. Profit target at any given moment.


What if the market moves against the trade?

The market is unpredictable! Like in any other strategy, we need to understand the risks of each position. Therefore, we need to manage properly the risks involved and trade accordingly. There are no risk-free options strategies! The strategy has hedges that we can use to reduce its risk in case the market moves against it. This mainly is a non-directional income strategy that uses time decay (Theta management) and IV decrease to realize profits.

How often do you trade this strategy?

I open a new trade per month. Usually, I am having 2 trades at the same time with 2 different expirations. This is the trade I use the most in the investment fund.

How often does this trade need adjustments?

This strategy is very stable and does not need too many adjustments. It will depend on SPX moves but, on average, less than one per week. Nevertheless, when the expiration approaches (below 30 DTE) it may need 2 adjustments per week. Under these circumstances, I will decide if it is better to continue and capture attractive Theta or close the trade. It will depend on the market status.

If I have questions, how can I clarify them?

If you subscribe to the trading community, you can easily use the Discord channel to enter your questions. Me or other community members will help you. Remember that you are not alone if you subscribe to myoptionsedge.com!

Or you can use my personal email with your questions and I am happy to answer: pedro.branco@myoptionsedge.com

Is this a difficult strategy to learn and trade?

No, it is not. The strategy description document will tell you exactly how to trade this strategy. Although it is not a simple options strategy because it uses several legs, it is straightforward. 

After 3 or 4 trades, you should have learned its fundamentals and you can trade for your own if you have the confidence to do so. the goal is to maximize Theta and minimize Delta risk, according to market short-term expectations.

Can this strategy be applied to other indexes?

I did not test it in other assets than SPX. But, it certainly will do well with SPY if you want to trade in a lower value.

For stocks or other indexes, I did not backtest it. But be aware that stocks tend to be more volatile than indexes, with earnings announcement events making them have big price swings.

How is this different from the $59/mo Trading Room plan?

The $59/mo Trading Room plan gives you live access to every trade I post โ€” but no structured course content. You see what I do, but not the underlying framework that explains why.

This plan adds the full SPX Best strategy course on top of Trading Room access. You can study the complete framework โ€” strike selection, adjustment rules, soft hedge logic, the full Greeks playbook โ€” then watch live trades that follow exactly that framework. It's the proper way to actually learn the strategy rather than just copy individual trades.

Best fit: if you want to understand WHY each trade is constructed and adjusted the way it is, not just follow signals.

How is this different from the $1,799 Core Fund plan?

Core Fund Strategies ($1,799/yr) includes THREE strategy courses: SPX Best, SPY Ride, and VXX Short Call Vertical โ€” the three strategies I actively run in my fund.

This plan focuses ONLY on the SPX Best strategy. The trade-off is straightforward:

โ€ข If you ONLY want SPX Best: this plan at $1,499/yr saves you $300. โ€ข If you want all three fund strategies: Core Fund is the better deal โ€” just $300 more for two additional complete courses.

Most members start here, then upgrade to Core Fund later once they're comfortable with SPX Best and want to add the other fund strategies to their rotation.

Can I upgrade to Core Fund later?

Yes, anytime. Your unused portion will be credited of your current subscription toward the Core Fund or Full Access upgrades. You won't pay twice for the time you've already covered.

Many members start with SPX Best, get comfortable with the strategy and the trading room rhythm, then upgrade to other Annual Membership after 3โ€“4 months to add SPY Ride and VXX Short Call Vertical to their toolkit.

Can I cancel anytime?

Yes.

Monthly: cancel any time before your next billing date. You keep access until the end of the current billing period, then auto-renewal stops. No questions, no friction.

Annual: paid upfront for 12 months. You can cancel auto-renewal at any time, but the current annual period isn't refundable (which is why annual carries a 26% discount vs. paying monthly).

Is there a free-trial period?

Not on this plan. Both the monthly ($169/mo) and annual ($1,499/yr) plans bill immediately on signup.

The reason is straightforward: the SPX Best course is the core deliverable, and a free trial creates a path for trial-and-cancel that's unfair to paying members. If you want to experience the trading room before committing to the SPX Best course, the $59/mo Trading Room plan includes a 15-day free trial โ€” that's the right entry point for "try before you buy." You'll see every live SPX Best trade I post during your trial, just without the course content.

If you decide the strategy is for you after the Trading Room trial, you can upgrade to this plan anytime and the unused portion of your trial month will be credited toward it.

The strategy is live. The next trade is coming.

Every SPX Best position I open goes into the Trading Room the moment I place it โ€” with the full rationale, the strikes, the payoff diagram, and the brokerage screenshot. The next trade will be there. So will every adjustment. So will the close.

The best way to learn this strategy is to watch it happen in real market conditions, alongside the community, with every decision explained as it's made.


Past performance is not indicative of future results. Options trading involves significant risk and is not suitable for all investors. All performance data shown is from a real account and is publicly documented on the Trading Account page.